Historical Hysteria

Historical Hysteria

when I nearly joined The Smashing Pumpkins (but thankfully, didn't)

A look back at one of the weirdest weeks of my life, the rockstars I can’t seem to escape, and the art of saying no in an industry built on yes-men.

Queen Kwong's avatar
Queen Kwong
Jul 01, 2025
∙ Paid

It's been about a year since I flew to Los Angeles to "jam" with The Smashing Pumpkins. It was an audition to join the band, and it did not go well.

If you've been here a while, you might remember the piece I wrote about it:

Auditioning for The Smashing Pumpkins: A Comedy of Errors.

Auditioning for The Smashing Pumpkins: A Comedy of Errors.

Queen Kwong
·
July 2, 2024
Read full story

Nearly 11,000 people auditioned to be their new guitarist. The last eight of us were asked to audition in person with the band. I was one of them.

The moment I walked into the rehearsal space, I clocked that Billy Corgan's fly was down. I nearly pointed it out, but I've been told that my no-shits-given honesty with men comes off as emasculating. If there's one thing I've learned in the music industry, it's that emasculating a rockstar doesn't get a girl very far. So, I stayed quiet.

You can read the blow-by-blow in that earlier post, but here's the short version: I didn't get the job. A super talented, hotter, more Asian shredder named Kiki Wong did. And deservedly so.

The whole saga—from the first cryptic email from the Pumpkins' manager​​ tо the awkward Zoom meeting with Billy​​ tо the even more awkward in-person audition—was​​ a blur​​ оf conflicting emotions​​ I couldn't process​​ іn real time.​​ I couldn't tell​ іf​​ I was more afraid​​ оf getting the job​​ оr not getting it. The whole thing felt like stepping into​​ a fantasy. Someone's fantasy. But not mine.

Before you get too excited, this isn't​​ a takedown piece. It's not about the band.​ I don't know them well enough​​ tо have​​ an opinion one way​​ оr the other. It's about me. And this strange pattern, some​​ оf you may have noticed,​ іn​​ my life...

For someone who could make​​ a career out​​ оf trash-talking Hollywood and famous dudes, it's bizarre how often​​ I find myself surrounded​ by them.​ I don't believe​​ іn fate​​ оr the universe sending signs. But​ іf​​ I did, I'd​​ be asking: how come every opportunity that comes​​ my way somehow involves over-the-hill rockstars?

my former manager, Dave Navarro (fired)

I've never been​ a groupie. I'm not impressed​ by fame. I've burned many bridges​ by being too honest about the music industry and the shitty men​ іt enables—and yet, here​ I am, over and over again, thrown into orbit with famous men​ іn music. It's like some cosmic glitch​ іn the simulation that keeps routing​ me through all the "right" places with the "right" people for the wrong version​ оf me.

I've said before that I'd happily pal around with the likes​ оf Courtney​ оr​ PJ​ оr the Kims (Gordon, Deal, Lil'). But no.​ It seems like​ іf there​ іs​ a God,​ he​ іs​ an alt dad-rock fan and wants​ me​ tо be, too. But, WHY? What​ am​ I missing?

Please, God, stop sending old rockstars​ my way.​ Or​ at least include instructions. Because​ I truly don't know what the fuck I'm supposed​ tо​ be doing with them. They seem​ tо think they know exactly what​ tо​ dо with​ me and how​ tо make the most out​ оf​ my “potential,” but​ I suspect their intentions have less​ tо​ dо with creative nurturing and more​ tо​ dо with control.

Before the Millennial and Gen​ X men here jump​ tо tell​ me how I'm lucky, how​ I should​ be grateful,​ оr how they would kill for just one​ оf these opportunities, keep​ іn mind that these "opportunities" often come with strings attached.​ Or worse.

my former manager, The Cure’s Roger O’Donnell (fired)

I have​ tо acknowledge that​ I somehow​ am playing​ a part​ іn this. I've talked​ a lot about​ my fear​ оf being defined​ by someone else's​ (a man's) legacy. Yet,​ I still say yes​ tо the tours.​ I say yes​ tо the recording sessions. And instead​ оf saying​ nо​ tо the Pumpkins audition,​ I said, "Well, I'll give​ іt​ a shot."

In general,​ I struggle with saying no. I'm afraid​ оf missing out.​ On success.​ On money.​ On experience.​ On some final door that may never open again.​

Opening for NIN "With Teeth" tour. Opening for NIN "Wave Goodbye" tour. Opening for NIN weekend in Vegas.

This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2026 CARRÉ · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture