i mean I was like 65% joking about the "just write poetry." but.... i don't get it. i said this already but it's music and good lyrics to enhance the music first and foremost. bad lyrics do make it a lot worse but they can't ruin it for me. good lyrics could nver save horrible music, though. no matter how good the lyrics. that's maybe the main difference in our opinions?
i say this as an erstwhile comparative literature major -- somebody who obsessed not just over words but analyzing them to death -- but what connects me to music almost always has nothing to do with the words but very much the actual music. how a certain unexpected chord progression hits me. how the the swell of a specific combination of instruments moves me. and then maybe once I'm already hooked I will also notice the lyrics. and if those happen to really be good... then wow, that's absolute gold. there are incredibly few exceptions to this.Tom waits, for instance. you're onto something about genre...I am very much not a fan of folk, and I think this is a reason for that.
also vocals matter, but my love for foreign language music (including foreign languages I don't actually speak) just adds weight to my preference.
fwiw I was also completely stunned by the poll responses. i couldn't believe 25% of music lovers would ever choose lyrics over music when it comes to, well... music!
edit: i got SO EXCITED after i voted on this poll bc i then i thought the screenshot from my poll were your results and i was like YEAH SUCK IT I WIN but obviously our readers want entirely different things lolol
Mark Twain said (and Jimmy Buffett quoted), “The difference between the almost right word and the right word is really a large matter. ’tis the difference between the lightning bug and the lightning.”
Even if "good lyrics can never save horrible music" part of how I think of the difference in being a lyrics-first vs music-first listener is whether it bothers you when a song makes a boring choice or picks a word just to fit an obvious rhyme.
Also in the music team, definitely. So few songs I listen for their words compared to how many I listen for their sounds. My Bloody Valentine anyone ? Lyrics are less important to me than the way words are chosen, pronounced, for their musicality rather than their meaning. Maybe the fact that I'm French and I fell in love with music in English is a reason, most of the time I didn't understand the words, especially for hip hop, too many words. My father couldn't understand, and tried to make me listen to the lyrics in French songs but I didn't care. I'm not saying lyrics can't enhance a song and send it to another dimension, they often do. Very Bad lyrics can also ruin a song, sometimes. But great sounding lyrics are more important than meaningful lyrics. I can also do without lyrics, post rock or drum & bass or Electronic music a la Autechre have been so important to me. Anyway, team music and I'm glad I'm not alone in this.
I thought of this conversation reading Matt Fish's post on _The Hissing Of Summer Lawns_. Obviously something that is musically unexpected is not the same thing as bad music, but it's a good reminder that, whether you are more drawn to music or lyrics, to have broad tastes.
"To say that critics and fans dismissed this record when it first came out would be to put it lightly. In his Rolling Stone review, Stephen Holden wrote that, 'If The Hissing of Summer Lawns offers substantial literature, it is set to insubstantial music. There are no tunes to speak of […] Mitchell’s tunes for the first time often lack harmonic focus. They are free-form in the most self-indulgent sense, i.e., they exist only to carry the lyrics,' adding that several arrangements are as 'pretentiously chic as they are boring.' . . ."
I’m a lyric girl all the way. My husband and I are lifelong Deadheads and don’t listen to Phish b/c the lyrics are so sophomoric that it drives us away. After singing a cappella in a church choir for 10 yrs, the message was clearly more important. Lyrics also create the “sing along,” which enhances the collective effervescence that takes us to higher ground. Wrote about it here:
Sorry, forgot to include some favorite lyrics. Ghost by the Indigo Girls - gut wrenching decades later. Woman On The Wheel by Gretchen Peters - my theme song. Lady Like That - Ingrid Andress. Suite Madam Blue - Styx. America, The Boxer, The Sound of Silence, etc - Paul Simon. Nothing Really Matters and One - Metallica. Going to California - Led Zeppelin. Us and Them - Pink Floyd. Time In A Bottle - Jim Croce. Black Hole Sun - Soundgarden. You Want It Darker - Leonard Cohen.
I love Ghost! I've dramatically filmed a music video for it in my head (starring me, of course) more than once. I feel like it's deep cut, have never heard it on the radio, found it through their 'greatest hits' album.
Brava. The debate will always rage on. Genres matter in the debate. Obviously, classical works, jazz pieces, etc. can say a lot without saying a word. However, in any genre with lyrics - the lyrics must tell a story or connect emotionally, regardless of the emotion, or I am out. I can forgive poor vocals and meh music if the lyric is compelling. I will not listen to great vocals and great music if the lyric is meh. I just can't do it. I love Gabbie and what she is trying to do here on Substack. That does not mean I don't struggle as an "old head" trying to listen to new music. The struggle to find new music that checks all the boxes is incredibly taxing these days. Maybe that makes me sound like an ass but it's my experience. Substack is helping me get out of my comfort zone discovering new music but it's not easy. I appreciate your perspective on this. And your Bruce cover was terrific.
Like I said on Gabbie’s post, I wish I were a music-first guy; it seems cooler. But I’m not, even though I don’t listen to a lot of consciously lyrics-first music. A dumb lyric can ruin a whole song for me, and I spend years, sometimes literally decades, on a lyric.
And no, poetry is not the same, because sometimes “yeah yeah yeah” is the perfect lyric.
I make music in order to express myself and I hope that someday I’ll learn how to sing properly so that I can add lyrics, that’s my ultimate goal. As a teenager, and in the many years since, I spent so many hours devouring the lyrics and trying to discern what they meant. It’s what gets stuck in my head. And far too many neurons are still hanging onto every word of Ice Ice Baby and Fresh Prince of Bell Air. I could recite every line without having listened in thirty years, lol.
With you on Sufjan and Fiona Apple! Amazing. Bowie is another one for me. Blackstar has a lot to decrypt. Thao is a great one.
Saul WillIams is someone everyone here might appreciate - he is literally a poet first and foremost. But a gifted rapper as well and Martyr Loser King is a perfect album. Burundi in particular will make you jump out of your seat and start a revolution. The Noise Came from here, especially when paired with the video might bring you to tears. He’s a genius.
Your lyrics are amazing btw. It’s what got me to listen multiple times in the first place - there are lyrics I deeply relate to - not the specifics details but in a visceral way of relating to pain and loss. Like you might be singing about your experience but some aspects of what you are saying remind me of how a family member treated me. And there are parts I don’t relate to, but kind of expand my perspective into what it is like for someone else, to be in their shoes, like how Boys for Pele challenged me as a teenage boy to see the world from another view
And the stories are ultimately what connects me too! I totally relate to that. Sorry that’s a lot. Oh well. I really enjoy this topic.
Oh that's so funny Michael, I remember being about 8 when Ice Ice Baby came out. Everyone at school could sing it, and every one of us felt so damn cool haha!
On the vocal side, I wouldn't worry so much about singing properly, just sing. I think its so easy to hold back on something - sounds like there's something waiting for you there pal!
Sending the best from a fellow musician in Berlin, wrestling with how to get stuff out as one gets older here! Jim
I would add Tori Amos to your list - amazing lyrics and great music! Agreed on the rest of it (I love Sufjan so hard, he's one of my fave lyricists).
And yes, for the most part, I am a lyrics gal. But good lyrics can't save shitty music, so it really has to be a combination of both for me. Once in a great while I can overlook bad lyrics for a catchy pop song...but the pop songs I like tend to at least have clever turns of phrase.
Very genre dependant. Joni Mitchell and Leonard Cohen are two of my favorite artists, even though I don't really like folk, solely because I love their lyrics. Their lyrics make me like their genre (when they do it.)
My favorite genre is metal though and when I listen to metal I *am* there for that sonic experience.
That said, even my favorite metal artists occasionally have really dumb lyrics and it does slightly dampen the listening experience to songs I would otherwise love.
And then there are my ULTIMATE favorite artists like QUEEN KWONG :) and Spiritbox who do both for me: intellectually intrigue me and emotionally grip me with their lyrics while making my ears happy.
But, while I love the idea of being such an intellectual that I'm just there for the words, I'm listening to music rather than reading poetry for a reason-- and I say that as someone who spends the majority of her day thinking about writing and literature.
I love this Alice "Their lyrics make me like their genre" - just a beautiful homage to the power of words. And all the more when the techsters have managed to make words endlessly regurgitate, as if thinking that will bring more meaning to things. I wrote a song called "Modern Monk" many years ago, direct from a poem. Hardly anyone ever heard it after it was released, but it was one of those moments where you feel you've delivered your entire being at one time of your life into what you're writing. All the best from Berlin, Jim
Ultimately, I have to agree with Gabbie on this one. If a song is a banger, the lyrics can be nonsense and I'll still sing along. Happens all the time. Good lyrics cannot save bad music for me.
I'm 60/40 on the music/lyrics scale. I'm greedy and I do pay attention to both. Like you said, good lyrics haunt me. When they are woven in to the right music, it imprints into your soul.
Completely agree. I'm very much a lyrics guy, though I think the music also has to be good. But I think most people don't care. Look how many mindlessly sing along to "I've got soul but I'm not a soldier" - quite possibly the worst lyric of all time - without a second thought. It's awful
Aside from being a (lovely) heated (friendly) bloodbath, I'd argue this is a bit of a false dichotomy. In some genres the words are super important, but in some less so, and in some there are often no lyrics at all. It really depends on what the music is doing for the social spaces and personal emotions it's trying to stir up.
"Where words fail, music speaks." Says a famous old guy.
Music is a way of conveying emotions in its own form, as each form of art is. When different forms of expression interact well, everything gets better!
Also, one of my fav lyricists worth mentioning: John K. Samson - both his solo work and his work with The Weakerthans.
I voted music, but it's not something I could pin down to a one-or-the-other. Most of my favorite music does have lyrics, and it's a struggle to get through a song where the lyrics are distractingly bad.
A lot comes down to the vocal delivery, or the vehicle, as you say. A lyric that isn't necessarily the most artful poetry on paper becomes cathartic and powerful when sang by somebody who can convey enough authenticity and emotion in it. Trent Reznor did a lot of that; Mike Patton is another. Some of your music could apply here as well--there's a whole lot of ways someone could sing "Sometimes I wanna die" and it would play as corny, but on "Medicated", it's chilling, and it becomes more powerful with each repetition.
Anyway, for great lyricists *and* musicians, I'd shout Beth Gibbons, Kristin Hayter/Lingua Ignota, El-P, Chelsea Wolfe, Emma Ruth Rundle, Amber Gazelle Valentine from Jucifer, Annie Clark.
Funny because I remember being in the studio with TR and watching him do a vocal take and thinking: wow, he’s a great…actor. And that’s something I’m not. I can authentically deliver lyrics in a live setting or within the first couple takes of recording. But after a few takes, it feels performative to me. Which is why I record everything on the fly. I’m just not good at faking feelings. In or out of the studio.
I’d also like to add rock lyricists: Alanis Morissette, Eddie Vedder, Jim James, Pat Benatar, and Florence Welch. Sheryl Crow is more rock than pop when she plays live, so add her in.
i mean I was like 65% joking about the "just write poetry." but.... i don't get it. i said this already but it's music and good lyrics to enhance the music first and foremost. bad lyrics do make it a lot worse but they can't ruin it for me. good lyrics could nver save horrible music, though. no matter how good the lyrics. that's maybe the main difference in our opinions?
i say this as an erstwhile comparative literature major -- somebody who obsessed not just over words but analyzing them to death -- but what connects me to music almost always has nothing to do with the words but very much the actual music. how a certain unexpected chord progression hits me. how the the swell of a specific combination of instruments moves me. and then maybe once I'm already hooked I will also notice the lyrics. and if those happen to really be good... then wow, that's absolute gold. there are incredibly few exceptions to this.Tom waits, for instance. you're onto something about genre...I am very much not a fan of folk, and I think this is a reason for that.
also vocals matter, but my love for foreign language music (including foreign languages I don't actually speak) just adds weight to my preference.
fwiw I was also completely stunned by the poll responses. i couldn't believe 25% of music lovers would ever choose lyrics over music when it comes to, well... music!
edit: i got SO EXCITED after i voted on this poll bc i then i thought the screenshot from my poll were your results and i was like YEAH SUCK IT I WIN but obviously our readers want entirely different things lolol
We are the perfect yin and yang. We should have our own podcast lol
This dynamic is what music and lyrics the romcom should have been about.
get somebody else to edit it and I'm in
I'll do it, im jobless
Mark Twain said (and Jimmy Buffett quoted), “The difference between the almost right word and the right word is really a large matter. ’tis the difference between the lightning bug and the lightning.”
Even if "good lyrics can never save horrible music" part of how I think of the difference in being a lyrics-first vs music-first listener is whether it bothers you when a song makes a boring choice or picks a word just to fit an obvious rhyme.
Also in the music team, definitely. So few songs I listen for their words compared to how many I listen for their sounds. My Bloody Valentine anyone ? Lyrics are less important to me than the way words are chosen, pronounced, for their musicality rather than their meaning. Maybe the fact that I'm French and I fell in love with music in English is a reason, most of the time I didn't understand the words, especially for hip hop, too many words. My father couldn't understand, and tried to make me listen to the lyrics in French songs but I didn't care. I'm not saying lyrics can't enhance a song and send it to another dimension, they often do. Very Bad lyrics can also ruin a song, sometimes. But great sounding lyrics are more important than meaningful lyrics. I can also do without lyrics, post rock or drum & bass or Electronic music a la Autechre have been so important to me. Anyway, team music and I'm glad I'm not alone in this.
I thought of this conversation reading Matt Fish's post on _The Hissing Of Summer Lawns_. Obviously something that is musically unexpected is not the same thing as bad music, but it's a good reminder that, whether you are more drawn to music or lyrics, to have broad tastes.
https://www.bestmusicofalltime.com/p/the-hissing-of-summer-lawns-by-joni
"To say that critics and fans dismissed this record when it first came out would be to put it lightly. In his Rolling Stone review, Stephen Holden wrote that, 'If The Hissing of Summer Lawns offers substantial literature, it is set to insubstantial music. There are no tunes to speak of […] Mitchell’s tunes for the first time often lack harmonic focus. They are free-form in the most self-indulgent sense, i.e., they exist only to carry the lyrics,' adding that several arrangements are as 'pretentiously chic as they are boring.' . . ."
I’m a lyric girl all the way. My husband and I are lifelong Deadheads and don’t listen to Phish b/c the lyrics are so sophomoric that it drives us away. After singing a cappella in a church choir for 10 yrs, the message was clearly more important. Lyrics also create the “sing along,” which enhances the collective effervescence that takes us to higher ground. Wrote about it here:
https://www.herizonmusic.com/p/vr-collective-effervescence?r=1n21y3&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&showWelcomeOnShare=false
THANK YOU. EXACTLY!
Sorry, forgot to include some favorite lyrics. Ghost by the Indigo Girls - gut wrenching decades later. Woman On The Wheel by Gretchen Peters - my theme song. Lady Like That - Ingrid Andress. Suite Madam Blue - Styx. America, The Boxer, The Sound of Silence, etc - Paul Simon. Nothing Really Matters and One - Metallica. Going to California - Led Zeppelin. Us and Them - Pink Floyd. Time In A Bottle - Jim Croce. Black Hole Sun - Soundgarden. You Want It Darker - Leonard Cohen.
I love Ghost! I've dramatically filmed a music video for it in my head (starring me, of course) more than once. I feel like it's deep cut, have never heard it on the radio, found it through their 'greatest hits' album.
Yes, highly niche. Not well known at all and one of the greatest lyrics ever written.
Brava. The debate will always rage on. Genres matter in the debate. Obviously, classical works, jazz pieces, etc. can say a lot without saying a word. However, in any genre with lyrics - the lyrics must tell a story or connect emotionally, regardless of the emotion, or I am out. I can forgive poor vocals and meh music if the lyric is compelling. I will not listen to great vocals and great music if the lyric is meh. I just can't do it. I love Gabbie and what she is trying to do here on Substack. That does not mean I don't struggle as an "old head" trying to listen to new music. The struggle to find new music that checks all the boxes is incredibly taxing these days. Maybe that makes me sound like an ass but it's my experience. Substack is helping me get out of my comfort zone discovering new music but it's not easy. I appreciate your perspective on this. And your Bruce cover was terrific.
i LOVE Gabbie! And she loves new music more than i do haha
Exactly!
Like I said on Gabbie’s post, I wish I were a music-first guy; it seems cooler. But I’m not, even though I don’t listen to a lot of consciously lyrics-first music. A dumb lyric can ruin a whole song for me, and I spend years, sometimes literally decades, on a lyric.
And no, poetry is not the same, because sometimes “yeah yeah yeah” is the perfect lyric.
as someone who makes a shit ton of noise and writes a shit ton of lyrics, i promise you: words are cooler. music-first guys are a bore!
Love this post!!!
I make music in order to express myself and I hope that someday I’ll learn how to sing properly so that I can add lyrics, that’s my ultimate goal. As a teenager, and in the many years since, I spent so many hours devouring the lyrics and trying to discern what they meant. It’s what gets stuck in my head. And far too many neurons are still hanging onto every word of Ice Ice Baby and Fresh Prince of Bell Air. I could recite every line without having listened in thirty years, lol.
With you on Sufjan and Fiona Apple! Amazing. Bowie is another one for me. Blackstar has a lot to decrypt. Thao is a great one.
Saul WillIams is someone everyone here might appreciate - he is literally a poet first and foremost. But a gifted rapper as well and Martyr Loser King is a perfect album. Burundi in particular will make you jump out of your seat and start a revolution. The Noise Came from here, especially when paired with the video might bring you to tears. He’s a genius.
Your lyrics are amazing btw. It’s what got me to listen multiple times in the first place - there are lyrics I deeply relate to - not the specifics details but in a visceral way of relating to pain and loss. Like you might be singing about your experience but some aspects of what you are saying remind me of how a family member treated me. And there are parts I don’t relate to, but kind of expand my perspective into what it is like for someone else, to be in their shoes, like how Boys for Pele challenged me as a teenage boy to see the world from another view
And the stories are ultimately what connects me too! I totally relate to that. Sorry that’s a lot. Oh well. I really enjoy this topic.
Love Saul Williams
Oh that's so funny Michael, I remember being about 8 when Ice Ice Baby came out. Everyone at school could sing it, and every one of us felt so damn cool haha!
On the vocal side, I wouldn't worry so much about singing properly, just sing. I think its so easy to hold back on something - sounds like there's something waiting for you there pal!
Sending the best from a fellow musician in Berlin, wrestling with how to get stuff out as one gets older here! Jim
I would add Tori Amos to your list - amazing lyrics and great music! Agreed on the rest of it (I love Sufjan so hard, he's one of my fave lyricists).
And yes, for the most part, I am a lyrics gal. But good lyrics can't save shitty music, so it really has to be a combination of both for me. Once in a great while I can overlook bad lyrics for a catchy pop song...but the pop songs I like tend to at least have clever turns of phrase.
Love Tori.
Words for songs that resonate. Music for background noise.
Very genre dependant. Joni Mitchell and Leonard Cohen are two of my favorite artists, even though I don't really like folk, solely because I love their lyrics. Their lyrics make me like their genre (when they do it.)
My favorite genre is metal though and when I listen to metal I *am* there for that sonic experience.
That said, even my favorite metal artists occasionally have really dumb lyrics and it does slightly dampen the listening experience to songs I would otherwise love.
And then there are my ULTIMATE favorite artists like QUEEN KWONG :) and Spiritbox who do both for me: intellectually intrigue me and emotionally grip me with their lyrics while making my ears happy.
But, while I love the idea of being such an intellectual that I'm just there for the words, I'm listening to music rather than reading poetry for a reason-- and I say that as someone who spends the majority of her day thinking about writing and literature.
I love this Alice "Their lyrics make me like their genre" - just a beautiful homage to the power of words. And all the more when the techsters have managed to make words endlessly regurgitate, as if thinking that will bring more meaning to things. I wrote a song called "Modern Monk" many years ago, direct from a poem. Hardly anyone ever heard it after it was released, but it was one of those moments where you feel you've delivered your entire being at one time of your life into what you're writing. All the best from Berlin, Jim
I love good lyrics, but it's music first to me. Even more so now that my hearing is trashed.
Ultimately, I have to agree with Gabbie on this one. If a song is a banger, the lyrics can be nonsense and I'll still sing along. Happens all the time. Good lyrics cannot save bad music for me.
I'm 60/40 on the music/lyrics scale. I'm greedy and I do pay attention to both. Like you said, good lyrics haunt me. When they are woven in to the right music, it imprints into your soul.
Completely agree. I'm very much a lyrics guy, though I think the music also has to be good. But I think most people don't care. Look how many mindlessly sing along to "I've got soul but I'm not a soldier" - quite possibly the worst lyric of all time - without a second thought. It's awful
agreed haha. Perhaps worst lyrics of all time that people sing along to mindlessly should be its own post.
Ha ha - all over that!!
Seriously! Hahaha. I can forgive some dumb/bad lyrics, but not that one!
Aside from being a (lovely) heated (friendly) bloodbath, I'd argue this is a bit of a false dichotomy. In some genres the words are super important, but in some less so, and in some there are often no lyrics at all. It really depends on what the music is doing for the social spaces and personal emotions it's trying to stir up.
"Where words fail, music speaks." Says a famous old guy.
Music is a way of conveying emotions in its own form, as each form of art is. When different forms of expression interact well, everything gets better!
Also, one of my fav lyricists worth mentioning: John K. Samson - both his solo work and his work with The Weakerthans.
I’m sorry Carré but I’m team Gabbie on this one.
I love music/lyrics that move…mood changing, crying, make me smile, drive faster.
The thing we all love about music is it’s subjective…there is no right and wrong, no definitive “top 10 ever” personal taste is personal.
All my favourite songs have good lyrics and good music while the songs I hate have neither.
One of my go to listens for decades are Mogwai and they’re predominantly instrumental.
The Hives are incredible live but lyrically basic.
The little I have heard of Coldplay I think they have some decent lyrics but I’d rather chew my own leg off than listen to them.
My badly made point is I can forgive bad lyrics but struggle with bad music. X
I voted music, but it's not something I could pin down to a one-or-the-other. Most of my favorite music does have lyrics, and it's a struggle to get through a song where the lyrics are distractingly bad.
A lot comes down to the vocal delivery, or the vehicle, as you say. A lyric that isn't necessarily the most artful poetry on paper becomes cathartic and powerful when sang by somebody who can convey enough authenticity and emotion in it. Trent Reznor did a lot of that; Mike Patton is another. Some of your music could apply here as well--there's a whole lot of ways someone could sing "Sometimes I wanna die" and it would play as corny, but on "Medicated", it's chilling, and it becomes more powerful with each repetition.
Anyway, for great lyricists *and* musicians, I'd shout Beth Gibbons, Kristin Hayter/Lingua Ignota, El-P, Chelsea Wolfe, Emma Ruth Rundle, Amber Gazelle Valentine from Jucifer, Annie Clark.
Funny because I remember being in the studio with TR and watching him do a vocal take and thinking: wow, he’s a great…actor. And that’s something I’m not. I can authentically deliver lyrics in a live setting or within the first couple takes of recording. But after a few takes, it feels performative to me. Which is why I record everything on the fly. I’m just not good at faking feelings. In or out of the studio.
Also, thank you re Medicated. Can’t believe you even know of that song!
I’d also like to add rock lyricists: Alanis Morissette, Eddie Vedder, Jim James, Pat Benatar, and Florence Welch. Sheryl Crow is more rock than pop when she plays live, so add her in.